Allen Matkins
ProfessionalsIndustries & ServicesNews & InsightsCareers

  • Professionals
  • Industries & Services
  • News & Insights
  • Careers
  • Offices
  • About
Manage Subscriptions

News & Insights

Legal Alert

Reverse Veil Piercing May Be Used to Reach an LLC's Assets

Real Estate

12.13.18

"Piercing the corporate veil" typically occurs when a judgment creditor proves that the individual owner of a corporate judgment debtor is the alter ego of that entity, thereby allowing the creditor to pursue the individual's assets to satisfy the judgment. Some jurisdictions allow "reverse veil piercing," which is exactly the opposite: a creditor with a judgment against an individual proves the individual is the alter ego of a corporate entity he or she owns, thereby allowing the creditor to pursue the entity's assets to satisfy the judgment against the individual. In a 2008 case entitled Postal Instant Press, Inc. v. Kaswa Corporation, in a case of first impression, a California court determined that reverse veil piercing is not an available remedy for creditors in California.

Recently, in Curci Investments, LLC v. Baldwin, California's Fourth District Court of Appeals distinguished Postal Instant Press and found that reverse veil piercing is an available remedy in certain circumstances. The Curci court noted that Postal Instant Press involved a corporation with innocent shareholders, while the Curci case involved an LLC owned by the judgment debtor (Baldwin) and his wife, who was already statutorily liable for her husband's debts. The Curci court also gave weight to the fact that Baldwin had used his control of the LLC to prevent it from making cash distributions that might have been used to satisfy the judgment. Finally, the Curci court noted that a judgment creditor's legal remedies were much more limited with respect to an LLC interest than with respect to the shares of a corporation. Ultimately, while it expressly declined to articulate a specific standard to be applied to determine whether reverse veil piercing was an available remedy to meet "the ends of justice," the opinion suggests that key factors will be the absence of innocent interest holders, the individual's use of the entity to protect assets, the existence of traditional alter ego factors, and the absence of traditional legal remedies (e.g. conversion, fraudulent conveyance) to provide a speedy, adequate remedy.

Potential Impact

Lenders should be aware of circumstances where reverse veil piercing may be available to satisfy a judgment against an individual, such as a guarantor who forms, owns and controls LLCs to protect his or her assets from collection. 

SUBSCRIBE

Author

Michael R. Farrell

Partner

Los AngelesT(213) 955-5527mfarrell@allenmatkins.com
Email Michael R. Farrell
Download Michael R. Farrell Vcard
Michael R. Farrell LinkedIn

RELATED SERVICES

  • Real Estate Disputes

RELATED INDUSTRIES

  • Real Estate

News & Insights

Manage Subscriptions

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Prevails in High-Stakes Leasing Dispute Against Mission Housing

3.04.25

Event

Los Angeles Commercial Real Estate CEO Outlook

2.25.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Event

Live Webinar: California Real Estate Outlook for 2025 & Beyond

2.25.25

Legal Alert

Los Angeles Wildfire Resources: What to do About Your Mortgage

2.19.25

Event

Managing your Construction Project as an Owner or Developer – Tips From the Trenches

6.12.25

Event

Development & Construction Trends in Mixed-Use/Retail & Multifamily

6.05.25

Event

Enhancing Bay Area’s Biotech Ecosystems and Innovation Hubs

6.05.25

Event

2025 Real Property Section Installation & Awards Dinner

5.29.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Landlord Sues Contractors Over $130M Lead, Asbestos at San Francisco Office Property

4.29.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins/UCLA Anderson Forecast Survey Podcast: Doubling Down on Retail

3.31.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Press, Media, & Articles

LA rental market gets even more competitive after wildfires

3.28.25

Event

California Assembly Bill 98 and the Implications for Infill Development

3.27.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Mayor Bass Backtracking On Measure ULA Pause

3.27.25

Event

ULI Los Angeles: Emerging Trends 2025

3.18.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Event

From the Top: Industry Leaders' Perspectives on Leadership & Professional Development

3.12.25

Event

ULI Los Angeles: StimULI: Digital Signage - Not Your Grandfather's Billboard

3.11.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Prevails in High-Stakes Leasing Dispute Against Mission Housing

3.04.25

Event

Los Angeles Commercial Real Estate CEO Outlook

2.25.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Event

Live Webinar: California Real Estate Outlook for 2025 & Beyond

2.25.25

Legal Alert

Los Angeles Wildfire Resources: What to do About Your Mortgage

2.19.25

Event

Managing your Construction Project as an Owner or Developer – Tips From the Trenches

6.12.25

Event

Development & Construction Trends in Mixed-Use/Retail & Multifamily

6.05.25

Event

Enhancing Bay Area’s Biotech Ecosystems and Innovation Hubs

6.05.25

Event

2025 Real Property Section Installation & Awards Dinner

5.29.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Landlord Sues Contractors Over $130M Lead, Asbestos at San Francisco Office Property

4.29.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins/UCLA Anderson Forecast Survey Podcast: Doubling Down on Retail

3.31.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Press, Media, & Articles

LA rental market gets even more competitive after wildfires

3.28.25

Event

California Assembly Bill 98 and the Implications for Infill Development

3.27.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Mayor Bass Backtracking On Measure ULA Pause

3.27.25

Event

ULI Los Angeles: Emerging Trends 2025

3.18.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Event

From the Top: Industry Leaders' Perspectives on Leadership & Professional Development

3.12.25

Event

ULI Los Angeles: StimULI: Digital Signage - Not Your Grandfather's Billboard

3.11.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Prevails in High-Stakes Leasing Dispute Against Mission Housing

3.04.25

Event

Los Angeles Commercial Real Estate CEO Outlook

2.25.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Event

Live Webinar: California Real Estate Outlook for 2025 & Beyond

2.25.25

Legal Alert

Los Angeles Wildfire Resources: What to do About Your Mortgage

2.19.25

View All
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Request Personal Data Information

Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. All Rights Reserved.

Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Instagram

This publication is made available by Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP for educational purposes only to convey general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this website you acknowledge there is no attorney client relationship between you and Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. This publication should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney applied to your circumstances. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Full Disclaimer